I'm always curious when a mascara starts getting a lot of attention on social media. Everyone seems to have their own favorite, but finding one that actually delivers length, volume, curl, and minimal smudging can be surprisingly difficult.


I decided to compare three popular formulas, paying attention to how they perform on my lashes, how their brushes work, and whether they live up to all the excitement. Honestly, my favorites weren't what I expected!


<h3>Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara</h3>


<b>Rating:</b> 10/10


This mascara was easily my favorite of the three. It delivers impressive length and volume, giving my lashes a fuller, more noticeable appearance without needing too many coats. The brush is slightly thicker than what I'm normally used to, but surprisingly, I don't find it difficult to work with.


What really makes this formula stand out for me is how beautifully it holds my lash curl throughout the day. Another big plus is that I don't experience smudging underneath my eyes, which is something I always pay attention to when choosing mascara. It gives me the combination of length, volume, and curl that I want without making my under-eyes look messy. Honestly, this one deserves its viral reputation.


<h3>Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara</h3>


<b>Rating:</b> 5/10


Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara has a curved brush that makes it particularly interesting for separating and lengthening lashes. I like the idea of its flexible brush design because it helps reach different areas of the lashes. However, the formula doesn't give me the volume I usually look for, so the overall effect feels a little too subtle for my preference.


My biggest issue is that it weighs down my lashes almost immediately, making it difficult to maintain the curl I want. I think someone with naturally fuller lashes might enjoy the length and separation more than I do. Unfortunately, the lack of volume and curl retention make this one less exciting for my makeup routine.


<h3>ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara</h3>


<b>Rating:</b> 2/10


I had pretty high expectations for ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara because of all the positive attention surrounding it, but this one was honestly disappointing for me. The formula weighs down my lashes, and clumping becomes noticeable even when I use the side of the brush with the smaller lash separator. I was expecting a more defined, lightweight result, so the experience wasn't quite what I wanted.


Another downside is the slight scent, which irritates my eyes.


That's a major drawback for something I'm applying so close to them. The only way I really enjoy using this mascara is on my lower lashes, where the smaller brush side gives me a little more control. Unfortunately, it doesn't work well enough on my upper lashes to become a regular favorite.


After comparing all three, Rare Beauty is the clear winner for me. It delivers the length, volume, and curl retention I actually want from a mascara. Tower 28 has some nice separating qualities but doesn't hold my curl, while ILIA simply doesn't work well with my lashes. If I were repurchasing just one, Rare Beauty would be my easy choice.